Street cleaning in Washington Heights may soon be reduced from two days a week to only one, after a vote by Community Board 12 on Nov. 24. Councilmen Robert Jackson and Ydanis Rodriguez both voiced support for the board’s resolution.
It is the first time such a decision has been made by a community board in Manhattan. It comes after the City Council voted last April to give Community Boards with clean streets the choice to drop one day in alternate side parking in residential areas. In April, CBS quoted City Council Speaker Christine Quinn as saying, “We’re not saying to a neighborhood you have to have less street cleaning and less alternative-side-of-the-street parking. We are saying you have that option.” And CB 12 has chosen that option.
Kathy Dawkins of the Department of Sanitation said that to be eligible, “each section of CB 12 must have a two-year street cleanliness rate of 90 percent,” which was the case for CB 12. This is measured by a scorecard from the Mayor’s Office of Operations, where inspectors rate the cleanliness of a district monthly.
The manager of Community Board 12, Ebenezer Smith, said that the board members were divided on whether to reduce street cleanings, the issue, with some even requesting “a return to street cleaning three days a week as it used to be some years ago.” But the board voted, 25-12-1, in favor of the resolution. Smith said some members argued that beyond the parking relief, it could also improve the air quality, since fewer people would be moving their cars around.
In addition to parking relief, Smith said the cleaning cutback could also save the city money. For instance, cleaning trucks will need less gasoline.
Smith himself was skeptical that the benefits would outweigh the detriments, though. He said that cutting street cleaning “might work in the area of Cabrini / 181st Street, but might not work in other areas, like St. Nicholas and 170th Street.” Indeed, St. Nicholas Avenue is said to be dirtier than, for instance, Broadway, due to a higher number of street vendors.
Vanessa Caballos, who lives on 173rd Street and St. Nicholas Avenue, said that so far the streets are clean because the sanitation trucks come frequently. But she is strongly against the new resolution. “Where is the garbage going to go? There are eventually going to end up on the streets,” said Caballos. She doesn’t own a car, but said that making parking easier for residents is not a good excuse “People who own a car in the city have to expect rules and regulations to be in place,” said Caballos. “Mass transit is the way to go.”
Now that Community Board 12 has voted to reduce street cleaning by one day, the Department of Sanitation will review the mechanical broom routes in each section of District 12. Dawkins said “this process can take up 12 to 18 months.” Once all changes are approved, the Department of Transportation will have to change the alternate side parking signs. And some residents can sleep in another day.









Recent Comments